U.S. Regulator Urges Congress to Act Fast on Crypto Regulation

CFTC Chairman says digital asset marketplaces should be regulated with tactics such as needing to register with federal overseers. 



The head of a U.S. trading commission on Thursday called on Congress to move quickly to regulate the digital asset market after the swift collapse of cryptocurrency exchange FTX.

In remarks made before the U.S. Senate Committee on Agriculture, Nutrition, and Forestry, the chair of the Commodity Futures Trading Commission said if Congress doesn’t regulate the digital asset sector it could harm not only cryptocurrency investors, but financial markets overall.

Never miss a story — sign up for PLANADVISER newsletters to keep up on the latest retirement plan adviser news.

“The events of the past few weeks embody—in the most regrettable way—the perilous state of the digital asset market,” Behnam said according to a prepared statement. “I strongly believe that we need to move quickly on a thoughtful regulatory approach to establish guardrails in these fast-growing markets of evolving risk, or they will remain an unsafe venture for customers and could present a growing risk to the broader financial system.”

The U.S. Department of Labor cautioned retirement plan fiduciaries to be careful in providing digital assets in 401(k) plans earlier this year, and the FTX collapse created a further chilling of interest among some advisers. Proponents of cryptocurrency in retirement plans point to surveying that shows workers—particularly younger ones—are interested in having access to digital assets in retirement plans.

Millions of 401(k) retirement savers currently have access to cryptocurrency investments through providers such as Fidelity Investments and crypto-investing proponent ForUsAll. Both firms this year have said they have made cryptocurrency available to workplace plan participants, with Fidelity making it available within the core plan lineup, and ForUsAll through the self-directed brokerage window.

Regulator Behnam told Senate members that if digital commodities are not regulated, it will leave consumers who have invested in digital assets “unprotected.” 

“Unlike other federal financial regulators, the CFTC lacks the necessary and direct authority to write rules and to oversee this marketplace,” Behnam said. “Instead, we may only reach it through more limited authority activated when fraud or manipulation has already occurred. While we can and do hold perpetrators accountable when we find fraud or manipulation, for the victims of the scheme, it is already too late.”

The U.S. Senate Committee on Agriculture, Nutrition, and Forestry and chaired by Debbie Stabenow, D-Michigan. Stabenow, along with ranking member John Boozman, R-Arkansas, in August introduced a bill called the Digital Commodities Consumer Protection Act (DCCPA).

In his remarks, Behnam recommended a shared regulatory responsibility between the CFTC and the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). The SEC would regulate digital asset tokens, while the CFTC would oversee a limited subset of commodity tokens.

The CFTC chair also suggested regulatory action such as requiring trading platforms targeting retail market participants to register with a federal market regulator. The platforms would be subject to requirements including the separation and protection of customer funds, maintenance of sufficient capital to operate, and public disclosures backed by independent, certified accounting, he said.

Without regulatory authority over cash digital commodity markets, the CFTC has relied on whistleblowers, Behnam said. These tips have led to 60 enforcement cases in the digital asset space since 2014, with total penalties of just over $820 million. In fiscal year 2022, more than 20% of the CFTC’s 82 enforcement actions involved digital assets.

“But as I suggested over a year ago, the fraud that we are able to prosecute is likely a fraction of what exists in the shadows,” he said.

Self-Directed Retirement Investors In Brokerage Accounts Stay in Equities Despite Volatility

According to a Charles Schwab report, the average account balance decreased approximately 20%, year-over-year.


Retirement investors who invest some 401(k) retirement assets through a self-directed Charles Schwab brokerage account saw their average account balances drop 3.55% in the third quarter of 2022 that ended September 30 compared to Q2 2022, and balances were down 19.84% year-over-year, new data shows.

The average account balance across all participant accounts finished at $273,412 for Q3, the Charles Schwab SDBA Indicators Q3 2022 Report found. That is lower than the $283,485 average value at the end of Q2 2022, and far lower than the average balance of $341,068 for 2021.

Want the latest retirement plan adviser news and insights? Sign up for PLANADVISER newsletters.

“Stocks rallied early but retracted their gains to close out a third consecutive quarter of negative returns; from its August 16 high to September 30, the S&P 500 Index declined nearly 17%,” the report’s asset balance summary stated.

SDBAs are brokerage accounts within retirement plans, including 401(k)s and other types of retirement plans, that participants can use to invest retirement savings in individual stocks and bonds, as well as exchange-traded funds, mutual funds and other securities that are not part of their retirement plan’s core investment offerings.

Equities remained the largest holding for participants in Q3 2022, at 33.43% of assets, with mutual funds at 28.4% and exchange-traded funds at 20.96%, the report found. Cash and equivalents comprised 14.74%, with fixed Income just 2.51%, data showed.

“Overall, participant holdings remained similar to last quarter, with an increase in fixed income,” stated the report asset balance summary.

The largest equity sector holding was information technology at 28.8%, the report found. The top equity holdings remained Apple at 12.5%, Tesla 9.6%, Amazon 4.8% and Microsoft 3.2%.

Investors allocated the largest portions of fund flows to large-cap stock funds at 33.7%, followed by 19.7% for taxable bond funds and international funds at 12.9%, according to Schwab.

ETF investors continued to push assets into U.S. equity at 51.7% of assets, followed by fixed income at 14.1%, international equity at 12.7% and sector ETFs at 11.3%, data showed.

Additional report findings:

  • Trading volumes were slightly lower, at an average of 10.6 trades per account, compared to 11.2 trades per account in Q2 2022 and in 2021.
  • Advised accounts held higher average account balances compared to non-advised accounts, $435,604 vs. $233,875.
  • Gen X had the most advised accounts at 50.0%, followed by Baby Boomers at 30.7% and Millennials at 15.8%.
  • Gen X made up approximately 46% of self-directed brokerage account participants, followed by Baby Boomers at 30% and Millennials at 19%.
  • Baby Boomers had the highest self-directed brokerage account balances at an average of $437,280, followed by Gen X at $246,206 and Millennials at $83,408.
  • On average, participants held 13 positions in their self-directed brokerage accounts at the end of Q3 2022, consistent with Q2 and similar to last year.

The SDBA Indicators Report includes data collected from approximately 186,000 retirement plan participants who currently have balances between $5,000 and $10 million. Data is extracted quarterly on all accounts that are open as of quarter-end and meet the balance criteria.

«