Full-Service Retirement Advisers Are Engaging in Busy Open Enrollment Season – With a Light Touch

Retirement advisories at companies also providing HR benefit, wealth management, and financial wellness are talking saving during this period of high inflation and market volatility, but with care not to overwhelm participants.



Retirement plan advisories working in firms that also have HR benefit and wealth management divisions are having a busy open enrollment season as plan sponsors and their participants are managing through a volatile financial picture, according to retirement experts at OneDigital, Marsh McLellan, and HUB International.

“This year is unique in regard to inflation and how it’s putting pressure on people’s paychecks, as well as market volatility and its impact on decision-making,” says MJ Goss, vice president of retirement and financial wellness with Atlanta-based OneDigital, one of a handful of firms that offers retirement planning, HR consulting, insurance, financial wellness, and wealth management under one roof.

Want the latest retirement plan adviser news and insights? Sign up for PLANADVISER newsletters.

With OneDigital’s full-service model, the retirement team can work directly with the benefits team to create a consistent experience and higher likelihood of action across their full benefit offering, Goss says. This takes open enrollment from a time to be avoided to a time to introduce an employee to their team of retirement advocates and their resources, according to Goss. 

Full service firms have been building up their holistic health, wellness, and retirement capabilities in recent years, boosting in particular their wealth management offerings via acquisition. The “adjacent revenue pools” of asset management and retirement are among the key growth trends for wealth management for the next decade, according to a 2022 report from consultancy McKinsey & Company.

Goss says open enrollment provides access to a lot of employees to promote awareness around retirement savings and other financial resources their employer may be providing. That said, the information should be bite-sized, accessible, and timely so participants feel the information is useful and relevant to their needs.

“We want to be timely with what we are providing during this window of time without overwhelming them,” he says. “I think if we do that it gets people saying, ‘my employer gets me and they have a team that is focused on making financial goals a reality.’”

A Family Matter

Katie Hockenmaier, a partner and US defined contribution research director with Mercer—a division of Marsh McLennan—says open enrollment is a time when employees aren’t just considering their own finances, but that of their family.

“From the retirement side, open enrollment is an opportunity because you have your employees making bigger life decisions and tending to engage with a spouse or partner around life planning,” she says.

Mercer looks to guide plan sponsors to provide educational or relevant financial topics that can link to overall retirement planning, Hockenmaier says. For instance, plan sponsors can institute a company match for people investing into a health savings account, or if they already offer that benefit, use open enrollment to remind participants of the advantages to the program.

Mercer’s recent research, she says, shows that financial concerns are even more in mind for people in the current market, with three out of four feeling financially stressed and concerned over having the ability to retire (second only to covering monthly expenses). With the wider network of benefit and wealth management offerings from Marsh McLellan, the retirement group can connect people to their individual needs, she says.

“We can hear the concerns of the employer and then work to implement the right solutions for them, whether that’s a managed account program or general wealth advisement,” Hockenmaier says.

Calls for Help

The current environment has participants looking more closely at their finances than in prior years, says Kim Cochrane, a retirement plan adviser and consultant with Raffa Retirement Services, a division of HUB Retirement and Wealth Management.

She notes that during the pandemic people saved on things like gas for commuting, getting food and coffee out, and happy hour drinks. Now, more people are back in the office, and coupled with inflation, budgets are tighter. People may need consultation and advice beyond just their retirement plan default rate, she says.

HUB, which is based in Chicago, has seen an uptick in participant calls with questions about their finances this year, Cochrane says. Even so, the advancement of retirement savings tools such as target date funds has most people maintaining the course with their savings, according to Cochrane. That’s a course of action she agrees with, at least until things stabilize.

“Most employees think they are more risk averse than they actually are,” Cochrane says. “So we tell them let’s recover, and then let’s readdress. If you’re uncomfortable right now then you’re probably not in the best risk adjusted portfolio, and we’ll look to pull back a little later.”

Cochrane and her team are connected to HUB’s other resources and interact with them for HR needs, insurance offerings, and savings options ranging from 529 college savings plans to retirement income annuities, she says.

“HUB has niche advisers and specialists and we can really channel those experts,” Cochrane says.

Goss of OneDigital says that they seek to get the firm’s resources in front of people as simply as possible. During open enrollment some plan sponsors will get a micro-site link that takes participants to a resource or contact page, or a QR code that brings them to OneDigital’s educational finance platform. Through this approach, participants can identify what is relevant to their situation.

“We really believe everything should be goal based,” Goss says. “It could be that someone wants to save for a new vehicle, or they’ve got kids going to college. The 401k may be the reason the door is open, but tools like Financial Academy, while still maintaining a retirement focus, are able to promote financial literacy across a multitude of topics.”

ESG Industry Put on Notice by Congressional Republicans

ESG investment strategy and the businesses around it has been sharply criticized and challenged by Republican leaders on all levels of government.


Senator Pat Toomey, R-Pennsylvania, wrote a follow-up letter to twelve ESG ratings and analytics providers on October 31 requesting that they keep documents related to the methodologies for their environmental, social and governance ratings.

Toomey is the ranking member on the Senate Banking, Housing and Urban Affairs Committee, and will retire before the next Congress is sworn in, and will likely be replaced by Senator-elect John Fetterman, D-Pennsylvania, this January.

Never miss a story — sign up for PLANADVISER newsletters to keep up on the latest retirement plan adviser news.

This letter follows an earlier letter sent September 20 to the same twelve firms asking for clarification on their ratings methodology.

He requested all non-proprietary methods for assigning ESG ratings. More specifically, he asked for how they engage with the companies they rate, if they employ analysts with sector specific expertise, if they have a revision process for errant ratings, if companies can dispute ratings, how they handle companies that do not provide requested information, how they evaluate data quality, if they consider political donations as a factor, and whether or not they use state-owned media as a data source in creating ESG ratings.

The letter also asked if involvement in fire arms, fossil fuels, or tobacco influences an ESG rating, and if so, how. These three industries, especially fossil fuels, are the most cited by Republicans when expressing skepticism or hostility to ESG strategy.

Six of the twelve provided responses. The other six either have not responded or provided responses that the Toomey considered “incomplete”. Institutional Shareholder Services, the parent company of ISS Media was one of the six that did not respond. The other five non-responsive ESG raters were Arabesque S-Ray, Carbon Disclosure Project, FactSet, RepRisk, and Sustainalytics

Senator Cotton, R-Arkansas, sent a more threatening letter to 51 law firms who counsel investors and other actors in the ESG sector.

Cotton’s letter was co-signed by four other Republican senators including Marsha Blackburn of Tennessee, Chuck Grassley of Iowa, Mike Lee of Utah, and Marco Rubio of Florida. Several of the law firms were contacted for comment and either declined to comment or did not respond to the request.

Cotton’s letter indicated that firms applying ESG investment principles The letter does not specify a specific industry such as investment advice or ESG ratings but suggests that the “ESG movement” is colluding “to restrict the supply of coal, oil, and gas, which is driving up energy costs across the globe and empowering America’s adversaries abroad.”

This alleged collusion could violate anti-trust laws according to the senators’ letter, and it says that there is no ESG exemption to federal anti-trust law. The letter advises the firms to store documents related to their communications with clients about ESG in anticipation of anti-trust investigations.

These letters follow similar warnings sent to Blackrock in August by 19 Republican attorney generals which alleged that Blackrock was privileging its “climate agenda” over its fiduciary duties. Another group of Republican attorney general last month sent civil investigative demands to the six largest banks in the U.S. to explore the AGs’ assertions that the banks’ ESG pledges have harmed the energy sector.

The Louisiana state pension fund also divested from Blackrock last month for their “blatantly anti-fossil fuel policies.” Other states, including Utah and Missouri, have divested from BlackRock with similar reasoning.

 

«