DC Plan Sponsors Making Decisions to Lower Plan Fees
Defined contribution plan sponsors are looking to negotiate recordkeeping fees, reduce revenue sharing and switch to lower-cost investments, a survey found.
Callan’s 10th-annual “Defined
Contribution Trends Survey” reveals that fees are playing a heightened
role in driving plan sponsor decision-making.
Reviewing plan fees
was cited as a key area of fiduciary focus, both now and for the
foreseeable future. Also related to this focus on fees are trends
including an increase in recordkeeper search activity, movement to
institutional fund structures, de-emphasizing revenue sharing, and
adoption of fee policy statements.
“Plan sponsors described their
review of plan fees as ‘continuous’,” says survey co-author and DC
consultant Jamie McAllister. “This includes both investment fees and
recordkeeping fees. Recordkeeping searches often result in fee
reductions. As a quarter of our survey respondents said that they were
very or somewhat likely to conduct a recordkeeper search in 2017, this
implies that fee pressure will continue.”
When Callan first asked
the question, in the 2012 survey, defined contribution (DC) plan
sponsors reported that the majority of participants paid administrative
fees solely through revenue sharing (36%) or partially through revenue
sharing (30%). In 2016, just over one-third (38%) said revenue sharing
was used in any way to pay such fees.
“In 2012, plan sponsors had
fewer fee payment options,” says Lori Lucas, CFA, survey co-author and
Callan’s DC practice leader. “Today, there are far more mutual funds and
daily valued collective investment trusts (CITs) without revenue
sharing, and even when there is revenue sharing, plan sponsors can
rebate it back to plan participants in ways that weren’t previously
available.”
Plan sponsors’ movement away from mutual funds to
CITs is also primarily driven by fees. Nearly two-thirds of DC plans
offered CITs in 2016, up from 48% in 2012. Meanwhile, mutual funds have
decreased in prevalence from 92% to 84% over that same period.
Fees
are also driving the increased use of indexed funds. In 2016, far more
plan sponsors reported increasing the proportion of passive funds in
their plan (12%) than increasing the proportion of active funds (2%). In
addition, more than 47% of plan sponsors have a written fee payment
policy in place, either as part of their investment policy statement
(21%) or as a separate document (26%). This is the highest rate ever
recorded in Callan’s survey.
NEXT: Plan design and investment findings
Callan’s 10th-annual “Defined
Contribution Trends Survey” also found the use of automatic contribution
escalation increased markedly over the past year (63% in 2016 versus
46% in 2015). Caps on automatic contribution escalation have also
markedly increased, from 19% in 2015 to 27% in 2016.
Nearly half
(47%) of plan sponsors reported making a fund change due to
performance-related reasons. This is the highest in the survey’s
history. Large cap equity was the most commonly replaced fund. Plan
sponsors also took action with their target-date funds in 2016, most
commonly cited was evaluating target-date suitability (67%) as the most
prevalent course of action.
In addition, the survey found that
largely in response to money market reforms going into effect, 64% of
respondents have changed to a different money market fund or eliminated
their money market fund altogether.
As for the Department of
Labor’s fiduciary rule will, DC plan sponsors believe it will primarily
impact the plan’s printed materials, website, and other educational
materials (43%) and communication regarding plan rollovers (43%).
Callan
has published the “Defined Contribution Trends Survey” each year since
2007. This year 165 U.S. DC plan sponsors responded, with more than 80%
having more than $100 million in assets.
Paychex’s
401(k) recordkeeping clients supported by LPL
Financial now have access to LPL’s Employee Advice Solution (EAS). This
online system provides plan participants with tailored financial advice and
education, the firm says.
The EAS can help employees digitally
visualize their entire financial pictures, and they can elect to receive advice
throughout retirement. Individuals also have access to advisers who can help
them personalize their retirement savings strategies.
Paychex points to a study by Morningstar
which showed that participants who received professional online advice for
retirement planning increased savings rates by nearly 28%, and 87% of
respondents acted on recommendations to save more.
“Paychex is committed to providing
401(k) participants with the tools and education they need to navigate the
retirement planning process with ease, flexibility, and service at every step,”
says Tom Hammond, vice president of
corporate strategy and product management at Paychex. “The ability to offer
plan participants access to financial advice from LPL Financial is another way
Paychex focuses on helping our retirement services clients optimize this
important employee benefit.”
EAS adds to the suite of tools and
services that Paychex offers through LPL’s employee Worksite Financial Solutions. The worksite offers retirement
guidance, education, and managed accounts. Enrollment in Worksite includes LPL Small Market Solution, which Paychex began offering to its
customers in 2016. The Small Market Solution is designed to help advisers and
plan sponsors met fiduciary requirements, while enhancing efficiency.
NEXT: Amerilife Names
New CEO
Amerilife Names New CEO
Insurance industry
veteran Scott R. Perry has been
named CEO of AmeriLife. He will succeed Timothy
O. North, who announced his plans to retire last year, and will now serve as chairman of
AmeriLife’s Board of Directors.
“The life and
health insurance industry is facing monumental disruption driven by shifts in
demographics, consumer preferences, technology and the regulatory environment,”
says Perry. “AmeriLife, with its diverse insurance product portfolio, powerful
distribution and advanced technology platform, is well positioned to respond to
these changes. I intend to build on the tremendous legacy that Tim and the
AmeriLife team created, and further position the company as the first choice
and most-trusted insurance provider, serving Americans across the country.”
Perry’s experience
in the insurance industry spans more than 30 years which included time spent as
chief business officer of the CNO Financial Group in Chicago, and president of
Bankers Life. While at CNO Financial, he was responsible for multichannel
operations across each of its three insurance subsidiaries: Washington
National, Colonial Penn and Bankers Life.
“We are excited to
have Scott take the helm,” says AmeriLife
Board Member Eric Rahe. “As an industry thought-leader whose intuitive and
innovative stewardship have led several insurance and financial institutions to
profitable growth, we welcome the perspective he brings to AmeriLife. His
experience and implementation of best-in-class practices in market analytics,
customer acquisition and agent recruitment will accelerate AmeriLife’s
continuing expansion.
AmeriLife specializes in developing, marketing and
distributing annuity, life and health insurance solutions.
NEXT:
New Sales
Consultant Joins The Retirement Advantage
New Sales Consultant Joins The Retirement Advantage
Grant Livingston has
joined The Retirement Advantage as
its regional sales consultant
serving the firm’s New England clients.
Focusing on retirement
plans, Livingston has more than 20 years in the financial and insurance
services industry. Before joining TRA, she served as a marketing director for Paragon
Alliance Group. He’s also held regional sales director positions with
MassMutual, Transamerica and WisdomTree Asset Management.
"Grant's background in
retirement plan consulting will enhance the service and support we're able to
provide to our financial advisors and recordkeeping wholesalers in the
region," says Craig Mazzini,
national sales manager of TRA. "We are thrilled to have him join our
sales team."
Livingston will succeed
David Egel, who is retiring at the end of February after a 40-plus year career
in the retirement plan industry. With TRA, Egel focused on providing consulting
to financial advisers and plan sponsors throughout New England. He is also an
attorney and a member of the Massachusetts and U.S. Supreme Court Bar
Associations.
TRA is a third party
administrator (TPA) specializing in administration, consultation and compliance
of retirement plans for privately held businesses nationwide. The firm services
more than 5,800 plan sponsors, 350,000 plan participants and has more than $5
billion in retirement assets under its administration.
NEXT: Custodia Financial Adds Staff to
Retirement Loan Eraser Program
Custodia Financial Adds Staff to Retirement Loan Eraser Program
Kim Zimmerman and Kevin Crews have joined Custodia
Financial with key roles in the firm’s Retirement Loan Eraser program, a platform designed to
help plan sponsors prevent 401(k) loan defaults.
Zimmerman
will serve as senior project manager responsible for establishing new users on
RLE. With more than 20 years of experience in the retirement services industry,
she has held several roles with Fidelity Investments. She earned a master’s
degree in business administration from The University of Dallas, and a
bachelor’s degree from Westminister College.
Crews
joins the firm as operations director overseeing insurance premiums, claims
processing, and other factors. Beforehand, he led an administrative unit
supporting retirement plans with Newport Group. He brings to his new role a
decade of experience in the financial services industry. He earned a master’s
degree from Amberton University and a bachelor’s degree in economics from the
University of Oklahoma.
"We
are thrilled to have talented professionals like Kim and Kevin join our team,”
says George White, executive vice
president. “Their experience supporting large clients at leading retirement
firms and their unique familiarity with the widespread issue of 401(k) loan
leakage will help Custodia move the industry forward to safeguard and protect
retirement loans.”
Cetera Financial Group Names President of Advisor Networks
Thomas B. Taylor has been
named president of
Cetera Advisor Networks,
part of the Cetera Financial Group.
He most recently served as senior vice president and chief operating officer of
Cetera Advisor Networks, and will replace Douglas S. King.
Taylor
will bring more than 26 years of experience to his new role. He joined the firm
in 1997 and has served in numerous leadership positions including chief operating
officer. Prior to joining Cetera, he worked for Securities Corp. where he spent
five years as a registered representative before being promoted to sales
manager.
Taylor, with more than 26 years of financial industry experience, joined Cetera
Advisor Networks in 1997 and worked across a series of management roles,
becoming chief operating officer of the firm in 2006. During that time, he has
been instrumental in developing many of the company's new operational,
technological and sales initiatives. Before joining Cetera Advisor Networks, Taylor spent five years as a top-producing registered representative at
Liberty Securities Corp./IFMG before being promoted to sales manager. He also
ran an investment program and managed a corps of advisers for a financial
institution in southern California.
Cetera CEO Robert J. Moore says, "As a longstanding
and highly effective member of the senior leadership team at Cetera Advisor
Networks, Tom has earned tremendous respect from the firm's advisers, regional
directors and staff for not only his leadership ability, but his depth and
breadth of knowledge of all aspects of the business. I am confident that Tom's
extensive familiarity with the firm's culture, coupled with his business
expertise, will enable him to continue to drive enormous success at Networks
through the delivery of exceptional support for years to come."
NEXT: Fiduciary
Investment Advisors Expands Retirement Practice
Fiduciary Investment Advisors Expands
Retirement Practice
Tyler
Polk has been named partner and senior consultant of Fiduciary
Investment Advisors (FIA). Since joining the firm in 2011, he’s served on
numerous committees including the defined contribution team and the 403(b)
Committee. Polk specializes in advising institutional clients and guiding them
through fiduciary liability, plan benchmarking, and participant education
planning, and fee analysis.
After joining FIA in 2009and serving as
senior consultant, Michael Chase has been named a partner.
He’s versed in portfolio construction, capital markets and governance
oversight. Chase chairs the firm’s Endowment & Foundation Committee and is
a member of the firm’s Discretionary Investment Services Committee, which is
responsible for the oversight and management of the firm’s discretionary
investment portfolios.
Christian
Coleman has
been named a partner and director of business
development and marketing of the firm. Coleman joined in 2008, and he leads
FIA’s sales and marketing team.
Matthew
Kaminski, CFA, has
been named a partner and director,
manager research of the firm. Joining the firm in 2009, he now leads the firm’s
manager research group and due diligence effort. He’s covered several asset
classes during his time at the firm and continues to maintain coverage in fixed
income and private equity, and also is a member of the 401(k)/403(b) Strategic
Oversight Committee which sees him conducting research on target-date and
stable value strategies.
“We are pleased to announce these
well-deserved promotions, which recognize the hard work and substantial
contributions these individuals have made in helping serve our clients,” says
FIA President Mark Wetzel. “FIA continues to grow in all of our major
businesses; advising retirement plans, endowments and foundations, and families,
now exceeding $50 billion, and we remain dedicated to providing the highest
level of service and advice to all our clients through qualified associates
like Mike, Chris, Matt and Tyler.”
NEXT: Segal Group Makes Executive Promotions
Segal Group Makes Executive Promotions
The Segal Group has named John Flynn the firm’s new chief
operating officer. Flynn serves as vice president and has lead the East
region for the past decade. In his new role, he will oversee the
regional Leaders from the East, Midwest, New York and West. Flynn also will
continue overseeing Segal Group’s Canadian business.
Senior vice president John Gingell has
been namedThe Segal Group’s chief
practice officer. For the past decade, he has lead the firm’s Midwest
region. He will now be responsible for the company’s practices spanning health,
retirement, and compliance; as well as special practices such as administration
and technology consulting, communications consulting, and Segal Select
Insurance Services.
Stuart Wohl,
a senior vice president, has been
named East Region Leader. In the last decade, he has served as East region
health practice leader. He joined the firm in 1988, and has also served as
Segal’s retiree health practice leader.
Mitchell Bramstaedt
was named the Midwest region Leader.
Throughout his 24-year span with Segal, this senior vice president has held
several Midwest leadership roles while working with large multiemployer and
public-sector clients.
“I am excited by what these changes
mean for our ability to better serve clients and to aid in growth and
professional development opportunities for my Segal Group colleagues going
forward,” says David
Blumenstein, president and CEO of The Segal Group.
NEXT: The
Standard Hires Retirement Plan Consultant
The Standard Hires Retirement
Plan Consultant
Matt Daniels has been hired by The Standard as the firm’s new retirement plan consultant for the East
Sales Region.
Daniels
brings to his new role 14 years in the financial services industry which he
spent working as a sales consultant for a boutique retirement consulting group
and as wholesaler for a recordkeepeing firm.
“Throughout
his career Matt has served in various roles within the industry, from
wholesaler to financial adviser, which makes him a well-rounded addition to the
team,” says Mark Bransford, regional
sales director for The Standard’s East Sales Region. “He’s able to step
right into the role of being a resource to our adviser partners.”
Daniels
holds the Accredited Investment Fiduciary designation from the Center for
Fiduciary Studies, as well as FINRA Series 7 and 66 securities licenses. He
also earned Michigan Life and Health Insurance licenses. Daniels graduated from
Wayne State University.
The
Standard offers financial products and services including group and individual
disability insurance, retirement plan products and individual annuities.