Another Health System Faces ERISA Excessive Fee Challenge

In yet another lawsuit involving the law firm Capozzi Adler, violations of the fiduciary duties of prudence and loyalty are alleged.

A new Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA) lawsuit has been filed in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania, naming as the defendant Universal Health Services Inc.

The complaint echoes the numerous excessive fee lawsuits that have been filed in recent years against all manner of large U.S. employers—from major universities to financial services companies to health care systems.

Never miss a story — sign up for PLANADVISER newsletters to keep up on the latest retirement plan adviser news.

According to the plaintiffs in the new lawsuit targeting Universal Health Services, the retirement plan in question holds more than $1.3 billion, qualifying it as a large plan in the defined contribution (DC) plan marketplace and among the largest plans in the United States.

“As a large plan, the plan had substantial bargaining power regarding the fees and expenses that were charged against participants’ investments,” the complaint states. “Defendants, however, did not try to reduce the plan’s expenses or exercise appropriate judgment to scrutinize each investment option that was offered in the plan to ensure it was prudent.”

The plaintiffs specifically allege that the defendants, as fiduciaries of the plan as that term is defined under ERISA Section 3(21)(A), breached their duties “by failing to objectively and adequately review the investment portfolio with due care to ensure that each investment option was prudent, in terms of cost; and by maintaining certain funds in the plan despite the availability of identical or materially similar investment options with lower costs and/or better performance histories.”

The complaint continues: “To make matters worse, defendants failed to consider lower cost collective trusts that were available to the plan as alternatives to certain mutual funds in the plan. Defendants’ mismanagement of the plan, to the detriment of participants and beneficiaries, constitutes a breach of the fiduciary duties of prudence and loyalty. … Their actions were contrary to the actions of a reasonable fiduciary and cost the plan and its participants millions of dollars.”

Similar to a rash of other lawsuits involving the law firm Capozzi Adler, this suit also names as defendants the company’s board of directors, arguing that they are in effect functional fiduciaries of the plan given their authority over the Universal Health Services organization. Likewise, the lawsuit names 30 individual defendants holding various roles with the organization.

Other allegations leveled in the complaint include that the majority of funds in the plan stayed relatively unchanged during the class period, which the plaintiffs suggest is evidence of a flawed fiduciary monitoring process.

“In 2018, a majority of the funds in the plan, at least 20 out of the plan’s 31 funds (65%), were much more expensive than comparable funds found in similarly sized plans (plans having over a billion dollars in assets),” the complaint states. “The expense ratios for funds in the plan in some cases were up to 203% (in the case of the Northern Small Cap Value fund) and 218% (in the case of the MSIF Small Cap Growth IS fund) above the median expense ratios in the same category.”

Universal Health Services has not yet responded to a request for comment. The full text of the complaint is available here.

CAPTRUST Continues M&A Push With Lakeside Wealth Acquisition

The addition of the $1.6 billion firm underscores the convergence of retirement plan advising and wealth management practices.

CAPTRUST Financial Advisors has announced that Lakeside Wealth Management, based in Chesterton, Indiana, has joined the firm.

The Lakeside team brings to CAPTRUST $1.6 billion in assets under advisement (AUA) and 27 employees, increasing CAPTRUST’s nationwide headcount to more than 700.

Never miss a story — sign up for PLANADVISER newsletters to keep up on the latest retirement plan adviser news.

This is CAPTRUST’s 41st transaction since 2006. Speaking last year with PLANADVISER about CAPTRUST’s planned merger and acquisition (M&A) activity, the firm’s leadership emphasized the importance of bringing together personal wealth management and retirement plan services business for future growth and profitability. The CAPTRUST leaders said the firm is eagerly building business models that can support advisers working with both private wealth management and institutional clients—adding that serving retirement plans and private individuals simultaneously does not mean its advisers will be aggressively soliciting rollovers or engaging in other potentially problematic cross-selling behaviors barred by the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA).

Instead, they said, building a firm that does both private wealth and institutional retirement plan business is about creating a holistic service ecosystem that clients want and need, especially as the defined contribution (DC) plan system matures and becomes a key component of individuals’ retirement income.

For its part, Lakeside provides retirement plan design, investment management and participant education for institutions. It also provides financial planning, retirement goal setting and legacy planning for wealth management clients. The firm was founded in 2002 by CEO Mark Chamberlain and is also led by President Tim Rice and senior leaders Chip Mang and Timothy VerSchure, who will all be joining CAPTRUST as principals.

“Lakeside Wealth Management is an ideal fit for CAPTRUST not only because of the alignment across their three lines of business, but also because they are a firm that prioritizes giving back to their community,” says Rick Shoff, a managing director in CAPTRUST’s Advisor Group. “Despite these unprecedented times, we are continuing on our trajectory of strong organic and inorganic growth.”

Shoff notes the firm has volunteered more than 20,000 hours and received many accolades for its efforts, including being named to the 2019 Invest in Others Charitable Champions List. Lakeside team members will now be able to work with the CAPTRUST Community Foundation, CAPTRUST’s employee-run nonprofit that seeks to enrich the lives of children in the communities the firm serves.

«

You have reached your limit of two free articles