PANC 2019: Health Savings Accounts as a Retirement Planning Vehicle

Increasingly, HSAs are being viewed, accepted, and treated in the industry, as a long-term investment strategy.

From left: Gregory F. Adams, Fiduciary Investment Advisors; Larry Bohrer, Charles Schwab & Co.; and John Manganaro, PLANADVISER. Photograph by Matt Kalinowski.


Larry Bohrer, vice president, corporate brokerage retirement services at Charles Schwab & Co. Inc., reminded us on Day Two of the 2019 PLANADVISER National Conference (PANC) that, unfortunately, each retiree will be facing about $300,000 in medical expenses. Health care costs are expected to rise 5.5% annually; therefore, upkeep on retirees’ health may be their largest expense. These statistics are from the most recent Devenir HSA [Health Savings Account] Market Survey.

But, reminiscent of the defined contribution (DC) marketplace in its early years, the growth rate of employees using HSAs is 20% per year, Bohrer said.

Want the latest retirement plan adviser news and insights? Sign up for PLANADVISER newsletters.

There’s an increasing awareness of the accounts by plan sponsors and participants, he said. “The tax benefits inside an HSA are better than in a 401(k). HSAs have a triple tax benefit and are portable, unlike flexible spending accounts [FSAs]. One of the lesser known benefits of having an HSA is that it lets people reimburse themselves for out-of-pocket medical expenses over an employee’s lifetime—if receipts are available.”

Gregory F. Adams, a consultant with Fiduciary Investment Advisors LLC, outlined the generally recommended hierarchy of savings: For starters, one should contribute enough to his DC plan to receive the employer match. If the person has a high-deductible health plan (HDHP), and it’s linked to an HSA, his next dollars should go to maxing out the HSA, per his annual IRS savings contribution limit, and after that into the DC plan.

Why aren’t HSAs seen as a long-term investment tool? “Twenty-two million people have invested funds in their HSA,” Adams said. “There’s an incredible range of investments, brokerage windows, money markets available, but there is still a huge gap in participant understanding that HSAs can have a long-term strategy.”

For instance, he said, parents of Millennials don’t talk about HSAs. “They still think ‘401(k) only’ when it comes to retirement savings.”

According to Bohrer, employers can save money by changing to an HDHP health plan, allowing employees the option to save in an HSA. An HSA, he noted, is like an individual retirement plan (IRA) for health care. 

Many recordkeepers are establishing their own platform for the accounts. Others have established partnerships, and some recordkeepers simply have HSA data integration. This is all being driven by employers seeing HSAs as a retirement savings account.

Interestingly, Adams, who is far down the road with HSA services offered, is getting ahead of regulatory bodies. “HSAs are taking the same path as 401(k) and 403(b) plans took 20 years ago,” he observed. “There are lots of vendors in the space, hidden fees, different restrictions, investment funds that are proprietary or not proprietary. We feel that, as HSA assets grow, regulatory bodies such as the IRS and the Department of Labor [DOL] will get more involved. We’re looking at RFPs [requests for proposals] for finding the right providers and documenting why we’re choosing the vendors we choose. We’re performing the due diligence so there are no compliance issues later on.”

Adviser Value Can Be Measured by Three Factors

Vanguard researchers emphasize that while the value of advice was once traditionally based on portfolio outcomes, goal success rates and advisory relationships are results of effective guidance as well.

Vanguard identifies the value of financial advice to investors as split into three factors: portfolio, financial and emotional.

In a new whitepaper, Assessing the Value of Advice, Vanguard researchers emphasize that while the value of advice was once traditionally based on portfolio outcomes, goal success rates and advisory relationships are results of effective guidance as well.

Want the latest retirement plan adviser news and insights? Sign up for PLANADVISER newsletters.

“It’s important to consider the broad definition of the value of advice and that it extends beyond traditional portfolio outcomes,” says Cynthia Pagliaro, senior research analyst with the Vanguard Center for Investor Research. “The three-part framework—portfolio, financial and emotional outcomes—presented in “Assessing the Value of Advice” is valuable for advisers who help plan sponsors craft advice offerings as well as measure their efficacy once implemented.”

According to the report, researchers studied goal success rates among Vanguard Personal Advisor Services (PAS) clients and found that 80% of participants with retirement goals had at least an 80% chance of fulfilling those ambitions, showing that financial advice is still highly valued among investors. This includes guidance on tax efficiency, fees, portfolio risk and return characteristics, and rebalancing and trading activity, according to Vanguard.

Additionally, Vanguard reports participants account emotional outcomes for 45% of total value to financial professionals, including feelings of trust, confidence and personal connection to the financial planning institution or adviser. Vanguard argues that while financial advice is imperative, value accounts for more than just quantitative measures. Financial institutions and advisers should be utilizing emotional factors, aside from a face-to-face connection, to engage participants, explains Steve Utkus, global head of investor research for Vanguard Investment Strategy Group.

“The element of emotional outcomes is not solely determined by face-to-face contact with an individual; emotional connections can be conveyed through the reputation of an employer introducing advice as a plan feature, or through the brand and reputation of the firm selected as the adviser,” he says.

While almost half of investors take emotions into account when valuing advisers, 55% value more operative aspects like portfolio management and financial planning. Emotional and financial outcomes are important for advisers to achieve, Pagliaro says, but not all portfolios will consistently be met with success.

“With respect to the latter, plan advisers need to consider measures that extend beyond returns,” she adds. “Even advised portfolios will experience periods of decline, but that doesn’t mean a decline in the overall value proposition for plan participants.”

«