Shifting Income Patterns Have Weakened Social Security’s Finances

AARP traces the erosion of Social Security’s taxable wage base to changes in wages, business income and investment returns.

A new report from AARP’s Public Policy Institute, “Shifting Income Patterns Have Shortened the Life of Social Security’s Trust Fund by 25 Years,” examines how changes in the distribution of income across the U.S. economy have affected Social Security’s finances. The report uses data from the Social Security Administration and the Bureau of Economic Analysis to examine how those changes have affected the program’s revenue.

The share of gross domestic product subject to Social Security payroll taxes, the program’s primary source of revenue, fell to 34% in 2025 from 41% in 1984. Based on official government statistics, AARP estimates that maintaining the historical share would have generated an additional $10.8 trillion in payroll tax revenue between 1984 and 2034—enough to pay full scheduled benefits through 2059, 25 years longer than the Social Security trustees now project.

Never miss a story — sign up for PLANADVISER newsletters to keep up on the latest retirement plan adviser news.

How Social Security Is Funded

Most Social Security revenue comes from payroll taxes paid by workers and their employers, each of whom contributes 6.2% of wages up to an annual taxable maximum. That cap was $184,500 in 2026. Payroll taxes accounted for 91% of the program’s revenue in 2025, while federal income taxes on some beneficiaries’ benefits provided another 4% and interest income accounted for the remaining 5%.

The revenue goes into two trust funds: Old-Age and Survivors Insurance , which pays benefits to retirees, their dependents and survivors, and Disability Insurance , which supports eligible workers with disabilities. The AARP report examined the funds on a combined basis because Congress has shifted money between them when necessary.

The combined trust fund grew substantially during the 1990s and 2000s, when many Baby Boomers were working and paying into the system. It peaked at $2.9 trillion in 2020, equivalent to about 260% of that year’s annual Social Security spending. As more Boomers retired and benefit costs exceeded revenues, the balance declined. The combined funds held $2.6 trillion at the end of 2025, generating $69 billion in interest income that year.

Escaping Taxation

Demographic pressures, including a growing number of retirees relative to workers, are often cited as the main reason for Social Security’s financial difficulties. But the report identified another important factor: a shift in national income away from wages subject to payroll taxes.

Rising business profits and investment income have shifted a greater share of economic growth from workers to capital, while wage gains have become increasingly concentrated among higher earners. Because wages above the taxable maximum are not subject to payroll taxes, more of that income has escaped taxation.

Growing earnings inequality has compounded the problem. Between 1979 and 2019, inflation-adjusted wages and salaries increased 41% for workers at the 90th percentile of the earnings distribution, compared with 9% for workers at the median and 7% for those at the 10th percentile. As a result, more wage growth has gone to higher earners, whose compensation is more likely to exceed Social Security’s taxable maximum.

The growth of pass-through businesses, including sole proprietorships, partnerships, limited liability companies and S corporations, has also contributed to the decline in labor’s share of gross domestic product. These businesses pass profits directly to their owners, who can classify more income as business profits rather than salaries, reducing the amount subject to payroll taxes. The report estimates that pass-through entities may account for as much as one-third of the recent decline in labor’s share of GDP.

Addressing the Gap

The report’s breakdown of national income provides another measure of this shift. Between 1983 and 2025, capital income—including corporate profits, business income, rent and interest—increased from 21% to 24% of GDP. Wages above the taxable maximum also rose, from 5% to 7% of GDP, while noncash compensation remained at 10%.

“Social Security’s finances have weakened in large part because the economy has changed while its revenue system has not,” said Rich Johnson, vice president of financial security at the AARP Public Policy Institute, in a statement. “Policymakers have options to explore to shore up its financing, including raising or eliminating the taxable earnings cap and applying targeted contributions to certain forms of capital or business income. The vast majority of people in America do not want their hard-earned benefits to be cut, and Congress should explore every option to avoid this.”

«