Alight Solutions has published March updates from its 401(k) Index, also noting that even with volatility returning to Wall Street, 401(k) investors were busy traders throughout the first quarter of 2022.
There were five above-normal trading days in March, often occurring when the market fell, Alight says. Despite the market rally for the month, investors continued to move money from equities to fixed income.
On average, 0.014% of 401(k) balances were traded daily, compared to an average of 0.02% last month. Investors favored moving assets into fixed-income funds during 15 out of 23 trading days. Trading inflows overwhelmingly went to stable value funds, while outflows were primarily from target-date, company stock and mid-cap U.S. equity funds, Alight says.
After reflecting market movements and trading activity, the index found average asset allocation in equities increased from 69.5% in February to 69.9% in March. Additionally, new contributions to equities increased from 69.5% in February to 69.7%.
In its observations for the first quarter, Alight notes there were 16 above-normal trading days in the quarter—a stark contrast to the three above-normal days seen in all of 2021. Net transfers as a percentage of starting balances were 0.46%, nearly equal to the percentage seen in the prior 12 months (0.53%). Net trading activity significantly favored fixed income.
Alight’s data shows that 42 out of 62 trading days in the first quarter saw net trading dollars moving from equities to fixed income, with the highest trading days generally occurring on days when stocks fell significantly.
According to the index, a “normal” level of relative transfer activity is when the net daily movement of participants’ balances, as a percent of total 401(k) balances within the index, equals between 0.3 times and 1.5 times the average daily net activity of the preceding 12 months. A “high” relative transfer activity day is when the net daily movement exceeds two times the average daily net activity. A “moderate” relative transfer activity day is when the net daily movement is between 1.5 and two times the average daily net activity of the preceding 12 months.
By using this site you agree to our network wide Privacy Policy.
Crypto Investing and Financial Literacy Across Generations
While most people in each generation still expect to rely on traditional income sources such as 401(k)s and Social Security in retirement, cryptocurrency has also made it onto the list.
In a new multi-generational financial literacy study, Investopedia suggests that while most U.S adults only have a beginner’s level understanding of cryptocurrencies, many still plan on using these assets as a key source of retirement funds.
The “2022 Investopedia Financial Literacy Survey” asked 4,000 U.S. adults—1,000 each from Generation Z (defined here as those 18 to 25 years old), Millennials (26 to 41), Generation X (42 to 57) and Baby Boomers (58 to 76)—about their financial know-how, habits, worries and retirement plans. The survey results suggest that Americans are simultaneously trying to grasp more about their personal finance basics while also learning about cutting-edge topics, such as investing in crypto.
While about half of Americans feel they have a strong grasp of financial literacy basics, such as spending, budgeting, paying taxes and saving, the survey notes that far fewer have the same level of understanding when it comes to more advanced investing topics. The same is true with respect to digital currencies.
Overall, 57% of adults surveyed are invested in some capacity, but just one in three say they have advanced investing knowledge. Even fewer (one in four) report strong knowledge of digital assets, such as cryptocurrency, blockchain holdings and non-fungible tokens. The survey results, according to Investopedia, show U.S. adult still have much more to learn.
The survey found that Millennials feel they understand investing the most, as 44% report advanced knowledge on the subject. Gen X follows closely behind (37%), followed by Gen Z (31%), and Baby Boomers (26%).
When respondents were asked about their knowledge of various financial concepts, even fewer people displayed a strong grasp of cryptocurrency, the blockchain and NFTs. Half of all survey respondents (49%) say they only have a beginner’s understanding of these emerging—and much-debated—aspects of financial technology.
According to the survey, Millennials are the most confident in this area, as 41% say they have an advanced understanding of digital assets. Similarly, 39% of Millennials suggest they could explain cryptocurrency to someone else, but only 25% say the same about NFTs. Members of Gen Z and Gen X are on about the save level, while Baby Boomers’ knowledge trails behind significantly.
Despite the gaps in knowledge, the survey shows that a sizable portion of each generation has invested in crypto and related assets, which Investopedia says indicates more emerging technology education is needed “to meet people where they are.”
Crypto-enabled investments are popular among three of the four generations surveyed—Gen Z, Millennials and Gen X. The survey says that 38% of Millennials have some kind of cryptocurrency investment in their name, making it the most common investment this generation holds and just as popular as investments in stocks.
Gen Z and Gen X are not far behind, with cryptocurrency as their second most popular type of investment, while the survey shows only 6% of the Baby Boomers say they hold the asset.
When asked what assets they expect to yield the greatest returns for them over the next decade, Millennials, Gen X and Gen Z all say cryptocurrency, followed by stocks. Baby Boomers think their stocks and mutual funds will produce the greatest 10-year returns, but cryptocurrency still surpassed more traditional investment vehicles such as index funds and exchange-traded funds, the survey notes.
Investopedia says its survey has affirmed that younger generations feel like they have more to learn about personal finance fundamentals, while older generations are focused on planning for the future and maintaining wealth. These findings, according to Investopedia, reinforce the need for ongoing financial education.
Gen Z say they are least educated when it comes to taxes, borrowing, insurance and retirement. They are also the generation that wants to learn more about doing their taxes, with 34% saying this is the most important financial skill they could learn today.
Millennials, who feel more informed when it comes to savings, investing and cryptocurrency than other generation, have their eyes on improving their credit scores, which the survey says is key for many common mid-life financial moves, such as buying a home or car.
Members of Gen X, many of whom are nearing the average retirement age, are most interested in saving for retirement. Baby Boomers, many of whom are already retired, according to the survey, are most interested in learning how to better protect their wealth by securing their personal online financial information.
“Our relationship to money, investing and financial planning has radically changed in the past few years, as new asset classes like crypto and NFTs have emerged just as millions of people are taking their first steps into investing,” says Caleb Silver, Investopedia editor-in-chief. “What hasn’t changed is the need for relevant financial education—but in a modernized curriculum that addresses these new financial products and services, designed to serve the people who are dependent on them to build their wealth.”
An earlier survey by Capitalize saw similar results, with 61% of respondents viewing digital assets as a strong retirement investment option, even though 57% view them as volatile investments. Yet, while more than half of financial advisers expressed confidence in crypto as a short-term strategy, they were slightly less bullish on its long-term.
One issue involves the risk that advisers assign to digital assets. Over 80% place cryptocurrencies in the “risky” category, with 76% considering such investments to be volatile. While 58% believe digital assets are “overhyped,” 55% still believe cryptos offer potential in retirement accounts.
When it comes to 401(k) plan fiduciaries considering plan investments in cryptocurrencies, the Department of Labor recently published compliance assistance to address the issue, with the goal of protecting the retirement savings of U.S. workers from extreme volatility and legal risks. Published by the DOL’s Employee Benefits Security Administration, the release cautions plan fiduciaries to exercise “extreme care” before they consider adding a cryptocurrency option to a 401(k) plan’s investment menu for plan participants.
In the release, EBSA says cryptocurrencies tend to be too speculative and volatile as investments to serve a meaningful purpose in tax-qualified retirement plans. As the release explains, at this stage in their development, cryptocurrencies have been subject to extreme price volatility, which may be due to the many uncertainties associated with valuing these assets. Other issues cited by EBSA include the speculative conduct of crypto market participants and the security risks demonstrated by widely published incidents of theft and fraud.
