This represents an 8% increase since the close of the third quarter and a 5% increase from the end of 2010. Lifecycle products (including both mutual fund and variable product) drew net inflows of $11.6 billion in the fourth quarter of 2011.
Mutual funds made up approximately two-thirds (or 68%) of overall lifecycle assets, and garnered $7.2 billion during the fourth quarter. Target-date mutual funds returned 6.85% on a weighted average basis over the quarter, and netted $9.1 billion in flows. Although target-risk mutual funds returned 6.23%, they experienced the second consecutive quarter of net outflows, with $1.9 billion of net outflows.
Target-date mutual fund assets remained concentrated among the largest managers. As of 2011, the five largest target-date mutual fund providers represented 84% of the market. Managers leading quarterly net intake for target-date mutual funds included Vanguard, Fidelity, T. Rowe Price, TIAA-CREF and J.P. Morgan Funds. In total, these five firms drew in $8.0 billion of net new assets.
The target-risk mutual fund competitive landscape is notably less concentrated than its target-date counterpart, with the largest five managers representing 44% of the $205 billion market. Top quarterly flow leaders included Fidelity, MFS, Manning & Napier, Franklin Templeton and DFA.
“Target-date funds continued to grow faster than target-risk funds in the fourth quarter. Target-risk funds saw net outflows in the last two quarters of 2011, ending the year with modest net outflows,” said Bridget Bearden, head of lifecycle research at Strategic Insight and author of the Lifecycle Fund Quarterly Update report for Strategic Insight’s FRC Division.
Variable annuity products represented $266 billion of lifecycle assets, with nearly all (96%) of the assets residing in target-risk strategies. The $255 billion variable target risk market attracted $4.0 billion of net flows, while posting net returns of 5.68% during the quarter. Variable target-date assets grew 9.6% over the quarter to $11 billion.
Despite fewer than 10 firms active in the variable target-date space, assets have grown by 31% on a year-over-year basis, driven by $1.4 billion of quarterly net new flows into the Prudential target-date series. The largest five variable target-date managers include ING, Prudential, Great West, Fidelity and Lincoln.
Approximately two-thirds of variable target-risk assets reside among the five largest players: Columbia, AXA Equitable, Prudential, John Hancock and MetLife. These five firms combined netted $2.4 billion during the fourth quarter.