For more stories like this, sign up for the PLANADVISERdash daily newsletter.
What Advisers, Sponsors Should Look for in a Private Markets Vehicle
As collective investment trusts emerge as the preferred structure for private market investments in 401(k) plans, experts say advisers will need to remain focused on strategy, liquidity and benchmarking.
As asset managers, plan sponsors and plan advisers prepare for a final Department of Labor rule to clarify the use of private market investments in defined contribution plans, collective investment trusts are increasingly becoming the preferred investment vehicle for bringing private equity and real estate exposure into participant portfolios.
Recently launched CIT investments with private-market exposures aimed at the DC market include offerings from Manulife John Hancock Retirement, Constitution Capital Partners, Principal and Goldman Sachs.
However, advisers evaluating these products need to look beyond the CIT structure itself and focus instead on the underlying investment strategy, liquidity mechanisms and manager capabilities, according to speakers at a Wednesday panel at the U.S. Media Summit by Natixis Investment Managers in New York.
Why CIT?
According to Sara Cassidy, managing director at AEW Capital Management and speaker during the conference discussion, “The Private Markets Moment,” advisers and sponsors can consider the right investment vehicle for their plan and participants as they await publication of the final DOL rule, which is currently being reviewed by the the Office of Management and Budget.
“We do think [private markets] can be a great opportunity for these plans, but [they] need to have the right access point,” she told the audience. “From an operational perspective, as well as on some fiduciary responsibilities for DC plans or DC advisers, one of the ways that these investments [become] attractive is through a CIT.”
Cassidy said CITs are the dominant investment vehicle in target-date funds. As of June 30, assets in CIT-based TDFs reached 55% of target-date assets, up 1 percentage point since the end of 2025, versus 45% held in mutual fund-based TDFs. At the start of the decade, CITs were the vehicle holding only 42% of target-date assets, while mutual funds held 58%. CITs and TDFs differs from how traditional defined benefit plans invest in private markets.
In a one-on-one interview with PLANADVISER, Cassidy said consideration is essential, since DC plans have different liquidity and rebalancing needs than DB plans.
“DC plan [participants are] expecting liquidity when they need it, based on their 401(k) plans, and there are a couple different mechanisms that the CIT can tap into, whether that is a liquidity sleeve that’s purely cash, [or] public securities, which can trade on a regular daily basis, that can provide liquidity. So those are options when you have that liquidity sleeve to solve some of the liquidity management and allow for more regular portfolio rebalancing,” she said.
When advisers and sponsors are evaluating whether or not a CIT suits their plan’s needs, Cassidy recommended that advisers weigh the same factors in a CIT that they would with other investment funds, such as underlying assets, performance history and drivers of future returns.
“We think about the performance of our vehicles and performance [of] strategies as being critical to being able to support the capital flows coming into the space,” Cassidy said.
Liquidity Remains a Key Consideration
One of the most significant considerations for sponsors and advisers evaluating private market allocations in DC plans is liquidity.
While private market funds have traditionally offered limited redemption opportunities compared with public market investments, Eric Deram, founder and CEO of private equity firm Flexstone Partners, a Natixis subsidiary, and a speaker, said the evolution of the secondary market for private fund investments has made liquidity less of a hurdle than it was in the past.
“The secondary market in private equity has become really efficient,” Deram said in an interview.
Deram noted that private market allocations within DC plans are expected to represent only a small portion of total assets, allowing the broader portfolio to meet most liquidity needs through public market investments.
For situations in which liquidity is needed, he said diversified private equity portfolios can often be sold in the secondary market within a matter of months and at significantly smaller discounts than investors would have faced historically.
Cassidy agreed that secondaries help create broader liquidity within private markets, but said defined contribution plans are unlikely to be direct participants in the market. Instead, she expected secondary-market activity to improve liquidity throughout the ecosystem and indirectly benefit retirement investors.
Adoption Will Take Time
While many industry participants view the proposed DOL safe harbor as an important step toward broader adoption of private-market assets in retirement plans, Cassidy said regulatory clarity alone is unlikely to drive immediate uptake.
“I think it will take more than just the rule to push for it,” Cassidy said.
She argued that education will matter as much as regulation, as advisers, sponsors and participants continue to learn how private market investments fit within defined contribution plans and what trade-offs accompany them.
According to Cassidy, distribution partners, advisers and end investors will need a better understanding of both the benefits and limitations of private market investments, particularly around issues such as liquidity.
“I don’t think the adoption, the takeoff, is going to happen immediately,” Cassidy said. “I think it’s going to be a very slow ramp up.”
You Might Also Like:
Victory Capital Taps Apollo for Private Markets Model Portfolios
More Plan Participants Familiar With, Interested in Private Investments
Anne Lester Explains How Private Market Assets Fit Into 401(k) Plans
« Plan Committees, Advisers Expand Focus Far Beyond Investments

