That brought total ETF net inflows
to $60 billion for the first five months of the year—a pace that could result
in the sixth straight year of $100 billion or more in annual net inflows to
U.S. ETFs, according to Strategic Insight, an Asset International
company.
Bond ETFs were the only major
category to post net inflows in May, drawing net nearly $8 billion. Equity ETFs
saw an estimated $6 billion in net outflows, with both domestic and
international equity products seeing net redemptions. Real estate and gold ETFs
also saw significant net inflows.
Distinguishing between education and advice is among
the most difficult issues when updating the definition of fiduciary, according
to a Department of Labor (DOL) official.
Basic education would not be
considered fiduciary in nature, whereas advice would fall under the definition,
but the distinction between the two is often blurry. “The line between advice
and education is among the most difficult we have had to answer,” said Michael
Davis, deputy assistant secretary for the DOL, during the 2012 PLANSPONSOR
National Conference. “It’s the most difficult philosophical question we are
dealing with.”
In October 2010, the DOL’s Employee
Benefits Security Administration (EBSA) proposed new regulations to update the
definition of fiduciary for purposes of the Employee Retirement Income Security
Act (ERISA). DOL Secretary Hilda L. Solis told lawmakers in March 2012 that the
agency is not rushing on its re-proposal of the new definition. (See “DoL
Not Rushing on Fiduciary Definition Proposal.”)
DOL has received more than 360
comments about updating the definition of fiduciary, Davis said. “This has been
a very interesting discussion,” he said. “And any time you touch the fiduciary
third rail, it’s going to be a passionate discussion.”
In determining what is advice rather
than education, Davis said it is sometimes unclear whether an “advice-like”
statement was made. In addition, recipients may not understand when they are
receiving advice rather than education. “Does a recipient understand being sold
a product versus being given broad advice?” he asked.
This will remain an important issue,
Davis said, particularly as Baby Boomers continue through the system. “We think
it’s a very important issue, and we’re taking all the comments we’ve gotten
under serious consideration.”