401(k)s Appear Ready for Retirement Income

Regulatory support and growing adoption of in-plan income solutions suggest advisers are shifting from evaluation to implementation.

Reported by Valentina Baez

Retirement income within 401(k) plans is not a new idea for fiduciaries. However, speakers at the 2026 PLANADVISER 360 Conference, in Orlando, Florida, said the industry has begun shifting from watching the market to adopting in-plan solutions. 

According to the discussion in “From Prudent Process to Product Readiness,” John Faustino, head of fiduciary governance solutions at Broadridge Financial Solutions Inc., said regulators in the past few years have worked to help create greater access to retirement income within defined contribution plans. This shows a strong signal of industry acceptance, he said.  

Faustino presented examples such as bipartisan support for the SECURE [Setting Every Community Up for Retirement Enhancement] Act and SECURE 2.0, as well as regulators’ support for the Department of Labor’s Prohibited Transaction Exemption 2020-02, which directly governs how advisers recommend rollovers and retirement income products.  

“If you look at the signals from the markets, there have been some really strong ones over the past several years,” said Faustino, citing recent developments such as Empower’s recently launched suite of four retirement income solutions, along with Vanguard and TIAA’s partnership for a guaranteed income target-date suite.  

“Vanguard got out of the retail annuity space in 2019. They’ve historically not been very engaged with annuities. So, the fact that they’re doing this in-plan, I think, is a big signal,” Faustino added. “You’ve got some of the biggest players in retirement that are committing to retirement income.” 

Increased Adoption Calls for Prudence  

Fiduciaries wanting to consider in-plan options for retirement income need to create a plan for measuring a solution’s success, according to Kent Peterson, senior vice president of institutional retirement solutions at Securian Financial and a panel speaker.  

“How do you create a prudent process, and how does that prudent process produce meaningful long-term success?” he asked the audience.  

Talking with advisers across the country, Peterson said, he found there was a gap between how they assessed traditional 401(k) investments and guaranteed income investments.  

“Advisers were saying, ‘I have a prudent process for evaluating investments. I don’t have a prudent process to evaluate insurance,’” Peterson said. 

In his research, Peterson said, he found it helped him to establish what expectations advisers had of recordkeepers regarding education about, and access to, retirement income products. 

“Over the years, I would travel with the distribution team and try to learn from the advisers,” he said.  

When Peterson asked advisers what they liked and disliked about retirement income products, “Right away, the term ‘complexity’ came up,” he recalled. He said he thought advisers were calling the products complex, since they are typically sold in the high-net-worth market, sometimes as individual annuities, and advisers often have to explain the details to individuals interested in buying them.  

“But as I dug deeper, it was more than that,” he said. Assessments are another big difference. With traditional investments, advisers measure historical performance and investment analytics; at times, they perform qualitative assessments and choose a fund that best meets their predetermined standards. Retirement income products cannot be measured that way. 

“Insurance is a future-looking product, and so it’s not necessarily about how the insurance company looks today,” he said. “[Advisers] said these products need to be separable. You need to be able to take the insurance and not keep it attached to a particular target-date fund. … The other thing was really [about] fees, transparency [and] benchmark-ability.” 

Peterson found advisers wanted retirement income that could be compared to other products available in-plan and out-of-plan. 

“There’s no reason to offer a benefit to participants in-plan, if they would get a better deal outside a plan,” he said.  

Recordkeeping Responsibility  

Ultimately, said Faustino, he thought resolving adviser concerns about in-plan retirement income will depend in part on how recordkeepers adopt retirement income products and whether those products support advisers’, and participants’, investment needs.  

“Retirement income is one aspect of personalization, and, to the extent these solutions are available only on one platform—because of an interest in a proprietary stable value offering, or whatever the case may be—I do think that’s a challenge,” he said.  

To address that challenge, the industry will need to expand access to retirement income products across recordkeepers of all sizes. 

“The way we’re going to overcome [the challenge] is when we have technology that democratizes access to solutions for some of the small to midsize recordkeepers, because then you can argue it up-market—if it’s being solved at the lower end of the market,” he said.

Tags
2026 PLANADVISER 360 Conference, prudent process, Retirement Income,
Reprints
To place your order, please e-mail Industry Intel.