While that assessment probably won’t shock our readers, a new study on the subject provides an interesting framework for plan sponsors worried that they might inadvertently find themselves in a litigant’s crosshairs.
Based on more than 2,400 ERISA cases filed between January 1, 2005, and August 31, 2008, “ERISA Litigation Study – April 15, 2009” is a statistical overview of pension lawsuits by category, court, and case disposition, compiled by Pension Governance, Incorporated and its PensionLitigationData.com partner, The Michel-Shaked Group.
According to the study:
- Nearly every case in the PensionLitigationData.com database is categorized as including an allegation of fiduciary breach. Other frequently cited issues include adherence to plan documents, the prudent man standard, remedies, and interference with benefits.
- ERISA litigation volume was highest for the 2nd federal circuit court (New York, Connecticut, Vermont)—where nearly one in five cases were tracked; and in the 3rd (Pennsylvania, Delaware, New Jersey) and 6th (Kentucky, Tennessee, Michigan, Ohio) federal circuit courts. Activity was lowest in the 10th (Utah, Colorado, Nebraska, Oklahoma) and 11th circuits (Alabama, Georgia, Florida), where just 4% (each) of the cases were brought.
- A majority of ERISA-related lawsuits settled out of court. More than one in five (22%) never got past the motion to dismiss, and another 28% were tossed at the point of a motion for summary judgment. Just 3% of all ERISA cases are disposed of at trial, according to the report.
- Numerous cases (38%) examined reflect an ERISA Section 502 claim. (ERISA Section 502 relates to civil enforcements.) Claims arising in the 2nd and 6th Circuits accounted for 33% of all Section 502 claims.
- Some legal venues favored plaintiffs in terms of the reported outcome. In fact, the study’s authors note that the 11th circuit “overwhelmingly favored plaintiffs’ (86% of the time) for the examined data set. Plaintiffs prevailed only 39% of the time in the 6th circuit, and just 40% in the 7th.
PensionLitigationData.com (PLD) is a subscription searchable database of pension litigation events. Focused on finance and investment issues, PLD includes cases posted since January 1, 2005. New cases are added on an ongoing basis.
The report is available here.