The judgments also provide for release of a fund holding more than $11 million, thereby making more money available to provide benefits to the ESOP’s participants and beneficiaries, according to the DoL. In addition, the defendants will be barred for at least 10 years from serving in a fiduciary capacity to plans, and the attorney service providers will be required to comply with strict requirements in connection with their future involvement with employee benefit plans.
Under the judgments and a settlement agreement filed in a related private lawsuit, the settling defendants must pay $8 million in cash into a settlement fund, pay $800,000 in civil penalties to the federal government and return property to The Employee Ownership Holding Co. with an estimated value of $4 million for the benefit of the ESOP and its participants, the announcement said.
In 2008, the DoL sued the firm’s board of directors, ESOP trustees, attorney, certified public accountant, and valuation adviser, alleging that the defendants imprudently used ESOP assets to purchase company stock from President and Chief Executive Officer Clair R. Couturier Jr. at an inflated price, and engaged in transactions that caused millions of dollars of harm to the ESOP and its participants, while enriching themselves (see “CA Firm Charged with Misusing ESOP Assets”).
In addition to $26 million in cash, in exchange for the stock, Couturier received a $5.5 million property in Palm Desert, California, $2.7 million in cash to pay taxes on that property, a $200,000 car, and a country club membership.