Compliance January 7, 2011
IRS Rules ESOP not Tax Qualified
The U.S. Tax Court upheld a decision by the Internal Revenue
Service (IRS) that an employee stock ownership plan (ESOP) and its
employee stock ownership trust (ESOT) are not qualified under the tax
code.
Reported by Fred Schneyer
Tax Court Judge David Laro asserted that the IRS was correct in deciding that the ESOP and ESOT plans of Michael C. Hollen’s dental firm did not qualify under tax code Sections 401(a) and 501(a) for the plan year ended on October 31, 1987, and for all plan years after that.
Laro explained that the IRS had four valid reasons for finding that the ESOP and ESOT were not qualified:
- The ESOP had not been timely amended to include provisions required by several sections of the tax code. Those sections included 402(c)(4)(C) (eligible rollover distributions), 414(n)(2)(C) (definition of employee leasing), 414(q) (definition of highly compensated employee), 414(u) (special rules for veterans), and 415(c)(3)(D) (participants’ compensation).
- Plan amendments that the ESOP adopted did not make the provisions effective as of the required effective dates.
- The ESOP did not follow the vesting schedule required by Section 411(a)(2)(B).
- The ESOP also failed to use an “independent appraiser” to appraise employer securities as required by Section 401(a)(28)(C), the court said.
The case is Michael C. Hollen D.D.S. PC v. Commissioner, T.C., No. 19618-08R.
You Might Also Like:
IRS Extends Relief on Inherited IRA 10-Year Rule Enforcement
The IRS notice said 2024 will likely be the last year for the relief.
Industry Players Not Concerned About PLESA Match Abuse
The Chamber of Commerce commented to the IRS that their members are not worried about participants contributing to PLESAs solely...
Commenters Request Eased Enforcement on SECURE 2.0 Part-Time Eligibility
Many stakeholders expressed concern with the administrative hassle of tracking the service of long-term, part-time employees and said compliance would...