‘Automated’ Savings Could Improve Retirement Income, per Morningstar

Four policy changes may allow more savers to accrue sufficient retirement income, according to a recent study.

Moving participants beyond access to retirement savings plans requires more from plan sponsors than making them available to workers. It also means getting people enrolled, encouraging them to remain in plans and providing incentives to save enough for retirement, according to new research from Morningstar’s Center for Retirement & Policy Studies.

In “From Access to Adequacy: Modeling Universal Automated Savings,” researchers Spencer Look, associate director, retirement studies at Morningstar Retirement, and Jack VanDerhei, director, retirement studies at Morningstar Retirement, examined four proposed policy models each designed to increase retirement-plan participation and improve retirement-income adequacy, defined as sufficient income for at least 100% of projected retirement expenses.

For more stories like this, sign up for the PLANADVISERdash daily newsletter.

Using Morningstar’s Model of U.S. Retirement Outcomes, they estimated that the combined proposals could increase the share of Generation X, Millennial and Generation Z households’ projected to have enough retirement income to cover their expenses to 67% from approximately 59%.

Expanding Plan Access

The first recommendation is to establish a federally administered retirement savings program for workers who lack access to an employer-sponsored retirement plan or a state-facilitated automatic individual retirement account. Workers would be automatically enrolled in Roth-style accounts at an initial contribution rate of 3% of pay, subject to existing IRA contribution limits, with the ability to opt out.

The potential benefit would be particularly significant for workers with little other opportunity to participate in a retirement savings plan. Among households with no expected future years of retirement-plan participation under current conditions, Morningstar projected that the share achieving retirement-income adequacy would increase to 48% from 37%. For Millennials in this group, the improvement was greater, raising the likelihood of reaching retirement-income adequacy to 51% from 32%.

Re-Enrolling Workers

The second recommendation would require automatic enrollment in all private-sector defined contribution plans, including existing plans that currently rely on voluntary enrollment. The proposal would extend to existing plans the SECURE 2.0 Act’s auto-enrollment requirements for newly established 401(k) and 403(b) plans.

Morningstar also recommended requiring federal, state and private-sector retirement plans to automatically re–enroll every three years any eligible workers who previously opted out of the plan. Workers would be re–enrolled if they remained eligible and were not already participating but could opt out again.

The provision addresses a weakness of automatic enrollment: Workers who initially decline to participate may never reconsider that decision. Periodic re–enrollment would give them additional opportunities to begin saving.

The researchers’ model assumed that 45% the workers that had previously opted out also would opt out during subsequent re–enrollment, compared with an initial opt-out rate of 30% for federal and state programs. This reflects the likelihood that some workers would continue to decline participation even when given another opportunity.

Expanding Savings Incentives

Finally, Morningstar recommended expanding eligibility for the federal Saver’s Match, which, starting next year, will provides a government–matching contribution to certain workers to add to their eligible retirement savings.

Current law, which takes effect in 2027, allows eligible workers to receive a 50% match on the first $2,000 in qualifying retirement contributions, for a maximum annual match of $1,000. Morningstar proposes retaining the 50% match but substantially increasing the income thresholds, so more workers could qualify.

Under the modeled proposal, the match would begin phasing out at modified adjusted gross income of $44,000 for single filers and $88,000 for married couples filing jointly, with eligibility extending up to $64,000 and $128,000, respectively. The proposed thresholds are illustrative and represent a substantial expansion of eligibility.

The proposal would also restrict access to any accumulated matching funds until age 62.

Morningstar also tested how increasing the initial automatic contribution rate in the proposed federal savings program to 5% from 3% would affect the results. Researchers found that change would raise the projected share of households achieving retirement-income adequacy to 67.6%, from 66.5% under the baseline proposal.

Improving Retirement Readiness

Improvements under the tested scenarios would be greatest among younger workers, with Gen Z households seeing a 12-percentage-point increase in projected retirement-income adequacy, compared with 10 percentage points for Millennial households and 5 percentage points for Gen X households.

Morningstar’s modeling suggests that the policies would particularly benefit lower-and middle-income workers. The share of Gen Z households in the second-lowest income quartile projected to achieve retirement-income adequacy would increase to 68% from 53%. Among Millennials in the same income group, the percentage achieving adequacy would rise to 64% from 50%.

The benefits would also extend across racial and ethnic groups, although disparities would remain. Morningstar found that Hispanic and non-Hispanic Black households would experience larger improvements than non-Hispanic white households, but substantial differences in projected retirement outcomes would persist.

The researchers noted that the paper’s universal proposals combine policy ideas that have featured in recent discussions, rather than reflecting a specific legislative design. The researchers stated that estimating the fiscal and administrative costs of implementing the changes was beyond the scope of the analysis.

«