Immediate Appeal Requested in AT&T PRT Case

Both sides asked the Massachusetts district court whether participants can pursue their pension risk transfer claims and requested partial final judgment for AT&T.

Reported by Emily Boyle

The parties in Piercy et al. v. AT&T Inc. et al on November 18 filed a joint request for an immediate appeal on whether participants can pursue their pension risk transfer claims and to enter partial final judgment for AT&T.

The appeal is based on a five-to-four split among federal appellate courts on plaintiffs’ standing to challenge PRT transactions.

On September 28, a judge in the U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts preliminarily ruled that claims against AT&T from a proposed class action lawsuit challenging the company’s $8.05 billion PRT to Athene Annuity and Life Insurance Co. should be dismissed. The federal judge allowed the claims against the fiduciary adviser selected by AT&T—known at the time as State Street Global Advisors Trust Co. and now known as State Street Corp.—to proceed.

U.S. District Judge Nathaniel Gorton, in his ruling, followed the report and recommendation filed by Magistrate Judge Paul Levenson on August 31, which stated that claims against AT&T should be dismissed on the grounds that the plaintiffs failed to demonstrate that AT&T was involved in the May 2023 selection of Athene as the annuity provider.

The U.S. 1st Circuit Court of Appeals, within which the U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts falls, has not issued a controlling opinion.

Standing to Sue

The memorandum filed this week argued that the case warrants interlocutory review, stating, “All parties agree that the order presents the kind of ‘difficult and pivotal questions of law not settled by controlling authority’ that are properly resolved through interlocutory appeal,” citing the Massachusetts district court’s opinion in Philip Morris Inc. v. Harshbarger.

The filing also stated that regardless of which party were to prevail, an immediate appeal would “materially advance the ultimate termination of [the] case,” citing one of the goals in favor of granting an immediate appeal, per federal law.

Final Judgment

The parties further agreed that the entry of a partial final judgment for AT&T would be warranted. The memorandum stated that because the court’s September 28 order “dismissed completely” all the claims against AT&T, partial judgment would allow plaintiffs to appeal the court’s ruling dismissing AT&T from the case on the basis that they did not have fiduciary responsibility for the selection of Athene. The parties agreed that issue was “distinct … from the factual merits issues pending in the case against SSGA Trust Co.”

“Further, no party will be prejudiced by the entry of partial final judgment,” the memorandum stated. “On the contrary, all parties and the court have an interest in prompt appellate resolution of two threshold issues in the case: Article III standing [to sue] and AT&T’s fiduciary status.”

O’Melveny & Myers LLP and Nutter McClennen & Fish LLP represent AT&T. Goodwin Procter LLP represents State Street.

Zuckerman Spader LLP, Schlichter Bogard LLP, Edward Stone Law PC, Libby Hoopes Brooks & Mulvey PC and Hopkins ERISA Law represent the plaintiffs.

None of the firms immediately responded to a request for comment.

Tags
ERISA, ERISA litigation, pension risk transfers,
Reprints
To place your order, please e-mail Industry Intel.