Compliance February 1, 2010
Court Refuses Broker Appeal for Pension Fraud Conviction
A federal appellate court has rebuffed a bid by former investment
broker Nathan Chapman Jr. to overturn his conviction for fraud against
the Maryland state pension system on "ineffective assistance of
counsel" grounds.
Reported by Fred Schneyer
Chief Circuit Judge William B. Traxler Jr., writing for the 4th Circuit Court of Appeals, ruled that it was properly the role of Chapman’s lawyer to decide whether to accept a court offer of a mistrial. The lawyer’s decision not to accept the offer despite Chapman’s wishes did not mean the lawyer was rendering ineffective assistance, Traxler asserted.
“To summarize, we conclude that decisions involving mistrials—whether to seek a mistrial or accept a mistrial offered by the trial court—are tactical decisions left to the sound judgment of counsel,” according to the ruling. “The decision remains counsel’s to make even if the client expresses disagreement with the decision, and counsel’s decision is not unreasonable simply because the client disagrees.”
Chapman, sentenced in 2007 to five years and three months in prison, was convicted in August 2004 of using state pension money to buy stock in his companies to prop up their value—a move that went sour when the stock value plummeted and the retirement system lost virtually all of that money (see “Chapman Jurors Convict on 23 of 32 Charges”).
Chapman once served as a chairman of the state university system’s board of regents.
“To summarize, we conclude that decisions involving mistrials—whether to seek a mistrial or accept a mistrial offered by the trial court—are tactical decisions left to the sound judgment of counsel,” according to the ruling. “The decision remains counsel’s to make even if the client expresses disagreement with the decision, and counsel’s decision is not unreasonable simply because the client disagrees.”
Chapman, sentenced in 2007 to five years and three months in prison, was convicted in August 2004 of using state pension money to buy stock in his companies to prop up their value—a move that went sour when the stock value plummeted and the retirement system lost virtually all of that money (see “Chapman Jurors Convict on 23 of 32 Charges”).
Chapman once served as a chairman of the state university system’s board of regents.
You Might Also Like:
Corporate DB Plan Funding Status Continues To Rise
Strong equity markets and stable interest rates have contributed to boosting funding surpluses.
Broker/Dealers Will Be Required by SEC Rule to Disclose More Information on Execution Quality
Rule amendments finalized this week will require broker/dealers to share more information on the quality of stock order executions and...
Senate Committee Advances Julie Su’s DOL Nomination—Again
Su advanced to the full Senate by an 11 to 10 vote for the second time in almost a year,...